To reproduce: Create a build (build A), which creates an artifact which is archived and fingerprinted. Configure this build to promote on both a successful completion of that downstream Build A, and a manual approval. Configure the promotion action step to run another build (Build B).

In Build B, select Copy artifacts->using permalink -> Latest promotion<promotion name>.

Run build A 4 times, getting build numbers 1, 2, 3, and 4. Promote build 3. Note that Build B copies over the artifact from the 3rd build of Build A. This is correct. Promote build 4. Note that Build B copies over the artifact from the 4th build of Build A. This is correct. Promote build 2. Note that build B copies over the artifact from the 4th build of Build A, instead of the 2nd build of build A. This is incorrect.