Uploaded image for project: 'Jenkins'
  1. Jenkins
  2. JENKINS-34971

Conditional build step plugin does not mark build a s unstable

    XMLWordPrintable

    Details

    • Similar Issues:

      Description

      "Conditional build step-single" shows nice field:
      "On evaluation failure" with options "Fail the build" or mark build as unstable.

      Unfortunatly this is not working.
      Example 1
      Run? = Never
      On evaluation failure = "Mark the build unstable"
      Builder = "Execute windows batch command"
      Command = "echo run builder"

      It should mark all builds as unstable and not run the builder.
      It does not run builder but does not mark build as unstable.

      Example 2 - more reliable
      Run? = Execute Windows batch Command
      Command = which notinpath
      On evaluation failure = "Mark the build unstable"
      Builder = "Execute Windows batch Command"
      Command = echo builder

      notinpath is not in my path, so evaluation should fail - it does.
      Build should be marked as unstable - it is not.
      Echo builder should not be runned - it is not.

      It Shouls mark all builds as unstable - but it does not.

        Attachments

          Issue Links

            Activity

            Hide
            fantastory Roman Wieczorek added a comment - - edited

            I think documentation is missleading. What does mean that evaluation failures?
            Does not it return a bolean value allways?

            Show
            fantastory Roman Wieczorek added a comment - - edited I think documentation is missleading. What does mean that evaluation failures? Does not it return a bolean value allways?
            Hide
            fantastory Roman Wieczorek added a comment -

            Currently docs says:
            "If the evaluation of a run condition fails, should the build fail, be marked unstable, run the build step ...
            A run condition evaluation may fail to run cleanly - especially if it is dependent on expanding tokens provided by the Token Macro Plugin and the values are expected to be present or look like a certain type i.e. be a number."

            Maybe it could be:
            "Action to take when can not evaluate condition - this is not same as evaluating to false.

            Should the builder run? Build marked as failed or unstable?

            A run condition evaluation may fail to run cleanly - especially if it is dependent on expanding tokens provided by the Token Macro Plugin and the values are expected to be present or look like a certain type i.e. be a number."
            "

            Show
            fantastory Roman Wieczorek added a comment - Currently docs says: "If the evaluation of a run condition fails, should the build fail, be marked unstable, run the build step ... A run condition evaluation may fail to run cleanly - especially if it is dependent on expanding tokens provided by the Token Macro Plugin and the values are expected to be present or look like a certain type i.e. be a number." Maybe it could be: "Action to take when can not evaluate condition - this is not same as evaluating to false. Should the builder run? Build marked as failed or unstable? A run condition evaluation may fail to run cleanly - especially if it is dependent on expanding tokens provided by the Token Macro Plugin and the values are expected to be present or look like a certain type i.e. be a number." "

              People

              • Assignee:
                domi Dominik Bartholdi
                Reporter:
                fantastory Roman Wieczorek
              • Votes:
                2 Vote for this issue
                Watchers:
                2 Start watching this issue

                Dates

                • Created:
                  Updated: